Here are constitutional and legal violations attributed to President Trump in 2025, backed by current reporting:
🧭 Major Alleged Violations & Overreaches
1. Illegal National Guard & Marine Deployment in Los Angeles
-
Details: Trump ordered deployment of ~4,000 National Guard troops and 700 Marines during immigration-related protests without state governor's consent, bypassing the insurrection act and Posse Comitatus Act—argued to violate the Tenth Amendment and state sovereignty.
-
California's Governor Newsom filed suit under the 10th Amendment and Title 10 U.S.C. § 12406 aclu.org+15theguardian.com+15time.com+15nypost.com+5gov.ca.gov+5time.com+5.
-
Legal experts warn this is an unprecedented use of military power in modern times apnews.com+9washingtonpost.com+9wired.com+9.
-
2. Birthright Citizenship Executive Order
-
Details: EO 14160 aimed to eliminate citizenship by birth for children of noncitizens—challenged as unconstitutional under the 14th Amendment's Citizenship Clause.
-
Blocked nationwide by federal courts, including Washington (Judge Coughenour) npr.org+7jeffries.house.gov+7en.wikipedia.org+7ogletree.com+3npr.org+3en.wikipedia.org+3.
-
3. Unilateral Revocation of Appropriated Funds
-
Details: Trump halted federal grants for public health and infrastructure through EO actions, ignoring Congress’s Appropriations Clause.
-
Lawsuits filed by states and NGOs assert he lacks authority to withhold funds once appropriated .
-
4. Frequent Emergency & Military Powers Overreach
-
Details: Trump has increasingly relied on emergency declarations and Title 10 powers to enact policies, deploy forces, and impose punishments—bypassing Congress.
-
Critics argue this pattern undermines democratic norms and violates statutory constraints (e.g., the National Emergencies Act) washingtonpost.com+1wired.com+1.
-
⚖ Summary of Constitutional Violations
| Violation | Constitutional / Statutory Basis |
|---|---|
| Deploying federal troops in LA | 10th Amendment, Posse Comitatus, Title 10 U.S.C. § 12406 |
| Birthright citizenship EO | 14th Amendment (Citizenship Clause) |
| Withholding Congressional funds | Appropriations Clause |
| Declaring emergencies/executive overreach | National Emergencies Act, separation of powers concerns |
✔️ What’s Next
These actions have triggered ongoing legal challenges and injunctions. They raise vital questions about:
-
Limits on executive power
-
Constitutional constraints on presidential authority
-
The preservation of state sovereignty
-
The judiciary’s role in enforcing constitutional norms
Here are the specific constitutional provisions and federal laws President Trump is alleged to have violated in 2025, along with the relevant text, citations, and sources.
1. 10th Amendment — States’ Rights & Unauthorized Troop Deployment
“The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution… are reserved to the States…”
-
Violation: Deploying 4,000 National Guard and 700 Marines to Los Angeles without Governor Newsom’s consent, in violation of the Tenth Amendment and federalism principles. Courts are reviewing its legality under Title 10 U.S.C. § 12406 and the Posse Comitatus Act (1878), which restricts federal troops in domestic law enforcement theguardian.com+15wired.com+15justsecurity.org+15.
2. Insurrection Act & Title 10 U.S.C. § 12406
-
Insurrection Act (10 U.S.C. §§ 251–255): Allows federal troop deployment only in cases of rebellion or insurrection, with state consent unless Congress authorizes otherwise .
-
10 U.S.C. § 12406: Authorizes calling up National Guard to federal service only under strict conditions (“invasion” or “rebellion”)—history suggests troop deploys without these criteria may exceed legal bounds whitehouse.gov+15justsecurity.org+15cbsnews.com+15.
3. Posse Comitatus Act (18 U.S.C. § 1385)
“Whoever… uses any part of the Army… to execute the laws shall be fined or imprisoned…”
-
Violation: Deploying Marines and federal troops to enforce civilian law (immigration protests) without a valid legal exception breaches the Act en.wikipedia.org+1cbsnews.com+1vanityfair.com+5wired.com+5washingtonpost.com+5.
4. 14th Amendment, Citizenship Clause
“All persons born or naturalized… are citizens of the United States…”
-
Violation: Trump’s EO 14160 strips birthright citizenship for children of undocumented or temporary visitors, directly conflicting with the 14th Amendment and 1898’s Wong Kim Ark precedent immigrationimpact.com+8whitehouse.gov+8americanimmigrationcouncil.org+8theguardian.com+10immigrationimpact.com+10americanimmigrationcouncil.org+10.
5. Appropriations Clause
“No Money shall be drawn from the Treasury… unless Appropriations made by Law…” (Art I, Sec 9)
-
Violation: EO halting federal grants after Congressional appropriation arguably violates this clause, which assigns funding authority to Congress alone .
🔍 News Coverage Navigation
✅ Summary of Violations
| Law / Amendment | Specific Text | Trump’s Action |
|---|---|---|
| 10th Amendment | Powers not delegated are reserved to states | Federal troop deployment over state objections en.wikipedia.orgcalmatters.org+15washingtonpost.com+15news.northeastern.edu+15 |
| Insurrection Act | Deploy troops during rebellion, invasion | Used Title 10 but without rebellion/invasion evidence |
| Posse Comitatus | Military cannot enforce civil law | Deployed troops for immigration unrest |
| 14th Amendment | Citizenship by birth | EO removes citizenship from U.S.-born children |
| Appropriations Clause | Money must be appropriated by law | EO froze Congressional grants |
